Arsenal and Newcastle Could Explore Swap Deal as Sandro Tonali Makes Decision on His Future

Newcastle United could be open to a swap deal involving Arsenal FC as interest continues to grow around Sandro Tonali, with reports suggesting the player is already open to leaving St James Park this summer.

Tonali’s future has become one of the major talking points ahead of the transfer window, with both Arsenal and Tottenham Hotspur monitoring his situation closely.

Newcastle are reluctant to lose him, but the growing pressure from top clubs has forced them to at least consider possible solutions, including a player-plus-cash or swap arrangement.

Arsenal, meanwhile, are exploring midfield reinforcements despite already having a strong season.

One idea being discussed is a potential exchange involving Arsenal midfielder Martin Zubimendi, who has been part of their successful campaign but is now being linked in broader transfer talks as clubs look to reshape their midfield balance.

Newcastle’s stance remains cautious, but internal discussions are believed to include how to keep squad stability while also responding to growing interest in Tonali.

The Italian midfielder is seen as a key part of Newcastle’s long-term project, but his openness to a move to London has changed the situation.

That has encouraged both Arsenal and Tottenham to stay active in the race, waiting for any sign that Newcastle could soften their position.

A swap deal is not Newcastle’s first choice, but it is understood to be one of the structures they would consider if it allows them to bring in a ready-made replacement while also avoiding a straight cash sale to a direct rival.

Arsenal and Tottenham pushing hard

Arsenal believe Tonali would be a strong fit in their midfield system, especially alongside Declan Rice, who remains a key figure in their squad. The Gunners are still assessing whether to make a serious push, but the opportunity to weaken a Premier League rival is also part of their thinking.

Tottenham Hotspur are also firmly in the race and are currently seen as more aggressive in their approach. Their project and promise of a central role in midfield could appeal to Tonali, especially if negotiations become more straightforward than Arsenal’s potential swap discussions.

Jenas weighs in on midfield comparison

Former player and pundit Jermaine Jenas believes Tonali would be a strong addition for Arsenal and even rates him above Zubimendi in terms of overall midfield impact.

He said:

“He’s a dictator of a game, he sets the pace and sets the tone every time he plays. He did the same when he was at AC Milan.

“When I look at that Arsenal midfield, I was never fully convinced by Martin Zubimendi, if I’m honest with you. I think he’s a decent, solid player, but Tonali would definitely be a level up in that midfield alongside Declan Rice.”